Top Shelf: McDavid's suspension, J.T. Miller trade scenarios, and more

Top Shelf, theScore's flagship hockey show, takes a weekly deep dive into the hottest topics and contentious debates in the NHL and beyond.

Subscribe to the show on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple. Episodes drop every Tuesday.

Hosts Aidan Thakkar, Levi Smith, Kyle Cushman, and John Matisz cover a wide range of topics in this week's episode, including:

• McDavid deserved his suspension (00:00)
• Unpacking the J.T. Miller trade market (04:15)
• Is Cale Makar on an all-timer trajectory? (11:35)
• Canadiens executing near-perfect rebuild (17:30)
• PWHL storylines at one-third mark (25:45)
• Sidney Crosby's average Joe qualities (31:20)
• Trivia! Guessing quarter-century teams (34:18)

Skyscanner | Score Top Shelf Travel Deals

Flights to Vancouver

Flights to Montreal

Copyright © 2025 Score Media Ventures Inc. All rights reserved. Certain content reproduced under license.